Before selling stamps, separate usable unused postage from collectible material, make a basic inventory, and choose a selling channel based on likely value, collection size, fees and the time you can spend.
First decide what you have
| Material | Key questions | Likely next step |
|---|---|---|
| Unused U.S. postage | Is it genuine, uncancelled and still usable for postage? | Compare face value with a realistic resale offer |
| Used stamps | Are issue, condition, cancellation and scarcity identified? | Organize before seeking a collector-market opinion |
| Albums or inherited collection | Is the arrangement, provenance or specialist grouping meaningful? | Keep intact until reviewed |
| Covers and postal history | Do envelope, route, date and markings form the collectible object? | Do not remove the stamps |
Prepare for an offer
- Photograph album pages, covers and better-looking individual items.
- Record country, approximate date range, used or unused status and obvious damage.
- Preserve old labels, certificates, invoices and the original arrangement.
- Do not clean, regum, trim, tape or separate material to make it look newer.
- For potentially valuable material, obtain more than one qualified opinion.
Compare net proceeds, not asking prices
The route table above identifies the relevant costs. The roll figures below are hypothetical offers and fees for arithmetic only, not a market valuation or published commission schedule. A roll of 100 genuine unused ordinary Forever stamps has $82 of postage value at the stated $0.82 letter rate; a buyer need not pay that amount. For an older collectible, identify and authenticate the exact item and condition before assigning any price.
| Example material | Channel and assumed gross offer/sale | Assumed seller costs | Illustrative net |
|---|---|---|---|
| One unused 100-stamp Forever roll | Postage dealer: $60 written cash offer | $0 if handed over locally | $60 |
| Same roll | Online marketplace: $75 completed sale | $10 platform/payment fees + $5 shipping | $60 |
| Same roll | Specialist auction: no assumed sale | Minimum consignment and handling terms unknown | Not calculable; ask whether the house accepts ordinary postage at all |
| Unidentified older collectible | Do not assume a sale price; request a written offer or comparable authenticated sale for the same item and condition | Actual expertizing, seller fee, insured shipping and return terms | Not calculable until identity, condition and real terms are established |
Request actual written offers and fee schedules, including who pays for certification, insurance and a failed sale; compare only after those details are known. A local buyer or club contact can make inspection convenient, but verify identity and payment before handoff. The American Philatelic Society’s collection guidance is a starting point for organizing material before solicitation.
Offer and payment safety
After inventorying the material and comparing written net offers, confirm who will pay for certification, shipping, insurance, returns and a failed sale. Keep a receipt or itemized consignment agreement for anything handed over, verify the buyer’s identity and payment timing, and do not pay an unexpected advance fee to release supposed proceeds. Pressure to decide before understanding the collection is a reason to pause.
This site does not buy collections or provide remote valuations. For the broader topic, return to the vintage stamps guide.
Sources and update note
Channel rules and fees change; verify them before a transaction. Checked September 10, 2026.